soapformulator
EN
Shaving soaps

Shaving croap

A wide tub of soft, glossy off-white shaving croap with a brush-swirled surface beside a shaving brush loaded with dense white lather and a dish of stearic acid flakes on a deep red backdrop

A soft shaving soap for a tub, halfway between a puck and a cream: half the oils are stearic acid for a dense, cushioning lather, and potassium hydroxide does 60 % of the saponification, so a damp brush loads in a few swirls. Unscented, with glycerin stirred in after the cook.

Skill
Advanced
Method
Hot process
Batch
500 g of oils about 876 g of batter
Hands-on
1 h 30 min
Cure
4 weeks
Gel phase
In the pot it gels as it cooks
Open in the calculator

Save to a list

Your lists

What you need

For 500 g of oils, which fills four wide shaving tubs holding about 200 g each. Weigh everything, liquids included.

Stearic Acid · 50.0 % 250 g 8.82 oz
Coconut Oil · 20.0 % 100 g 3.53 oz
Shea Butter · 15.0 % 75 g 2.65 oz
Castor Oil · 10.0 % 50 g 1.76 oz
Olive Oil · 5.0 % 25 g 0.88 oz
Sodium hydroxide (NaOH) · the lye, 100 % pure 28.8 g 1.02 oz
Potassium hydroxide (KOH) · the lye, 90 % pure; if your label says otherwise, weigh 71.4 g at 85 % or 63.9 g at 95 % 67.4 g 2.38 oz
Distilled water · for a 28 % lye solution 250.0 g 8.82 oz
Glycerin · stirred into the hot soap after the cook 30 g 1.06 oz
Superfat
4 %
Temperatures
Fats held above 60 °C (140 °F) so the stearic acid stays melted, lye solution cooled below 82 °C (180 °F), cooked on low

Resize or change it in the calculator

Method

  1. Get ready

    Put on splash goggles, gloves and long sleeves, and keep them on until the croap is in its tubs. Weigh 250 g stearic acid, 100 g coconut oil and 75 g shea butter into a slow cooker, 50 g castor oil and 25 g olive oil into a jug, 250 g distilled water into a heat-proof jug, and 28.8 g sodium hydroxide and 67.4 g potassium hydroxide flakes into two dry containers; close the flake tub at once.
  2. Make the lye solution

    At an open window, stir the sodium hydroxide and then the potassium hydroxide into the water a little at a time, always lye into water. Potassium hydroxide fizzes loudly and the solution gets very hot; keep it away from aluminium and let it cool below 82 °C (180 °F) while you melt the fats.
  3. Melt the fats hot

    Melt the stearic acid, coconut oil and shea butter in the slow cooker on high, stir in the castor and olive oils, and turn the cooker to low. Half of this fat is stearic acid, which sets at about 55 °C (131 °F), so hold the blend above 60 °C (140 °F).
  4. Pour in the lye

    Pour the lye solution into the fats in one steady stream, stirring hard with a sturdy spatula. The batter turns milky and thickens to a paste almost at once as the stearic acid becomes soap.
  5. Work it smooth

    Break the paste up with short bursts of the stick blender and the spatula until it is even and no liquid lye pools in the pot. With more water and more potassium than a puck, it stays softer and stickier, like thick, heavy cream cheese.
  6. Cook it through

    Cover and cook on low for about an hour, folding it over every 15 to 20 minutes and scraping the edges back into the middle, and stirring it down if it puffs up.
  7. Check it is done

    It is ready when it is glossy and translucent right through, like petroleum jelly, with no opaque white streaks when you fold it. If you have phenolphthalein, a drop on a smear should turn only a faint, slow pink; a vivid magenta at once means another 20 to 30 minutes.
  8. Stir in the glycerin

    Turn off the cooker and stir the 30 g of glycerin through the hot soap until it disappears. It loosens the croap a little, which makes the tubs easier to fill.
  9. Fill the tubs

    Spoon the hot croap into four wide tubs, pressing each spoonful down to push out air and tapping the tub on the bench, and smooth the tops with the back of a spoon.
  10. Let it firm

    Leave the tubs open somewhere airy for four weeks, then put the lids on. It firms to a dense, soft soap that holds its shape but takes the print of a fingernail, and it loses a little water and weight as it goes.
  11. Load the brush

    To use it, wet the brush, shake it out and swirl it on the croap for ten seconds or so; it loads far faster than a hard puck. Build the lather in a bowl or on your face, adding water a few drops at a time.

Tips

  • Potassium hydroxide does 60 % of the saponification, so its purity matters more here than in a puck. The recipe assumes 90 % flakes; with 95 % flakes the same weight takes the superfat from 4 % to about 0.8 %, so enter the figure on your label in the calculator before you weigh.
  • Keep the superfat at 4 %. At 2 % the spread of published saponification values for these oils could leave the croap with a trace of free lye, and it goes on freshly shaved skin.
  • If it comes out softer than you like, lower the potassium share in the calculator for the next batch, towards the 40 % of our shaving soap puck; for something softer still, to scoop by hand, see the cream soap. Both lyes change when you do.
  • To scent it, stir essential oil into the hot soap after the glycerin, once it is below about 82 °C (180 °F), at 2 to 3 % of the oils, and check any oil with an IFRA limit in the calculator first.

Why make it

A croap sits between a puck and a cream. Half its oils are stearic acid and potassium hydroxide does 60 % of the saponification, so it stays soft enough to load a damp brush in a few swirls yet holds its shape in a tub. On our scale it scores 69 for creamy lather and 15 for cleansing: a dense, cushioning lather that does not strip. Glycerin goes back in because free stearic acid makes none. Wet shavers who find hard pucks slow to load often choose a croap, a preference that rests on experience rather than trials. It is left unscented, in line with the American Academy of Dermatology's advice to look for fragrance-free products, and shaving creams made for sensitive skin, if your skin is dry or sensitive. The price of softness is that it wears down faster than a puck.

Sources

What tradition, makers' experience and research say about soaps like this, each labelled for what it is. It is not medical advice, and no soap treats a skin condition: if you have one, ask a doctor or pharmacist.

What the numbers say

  • Lauric acid 9.8 %
  • Myristic acid 4.8 %
  • Palmitic acid 26.7 %
  • Stearic acid 33.2 %
  • Ricinoleic acid 8.9 %
  • Oleic acid 12.7 %
  • Linoleic acid 3.1 %
  • Other 3.2 %

Saturated : unsaturated 76 : 24

Hardness 75 above 29–54
Cleansing 15 12–22
Conditioning 25 below 44–69
Bubbly lather 23 14–46
Creamy lather 69 above 16–48

Computed from the fatty acids of the fats above. The bands are what the craft has settled on, not chemistry — a bar outside one is not wrong.

Try it differently

6 variations

The same soap with one thing moved. Each opens in the calculator ready to change again.

From the guides

All guides

Where these proportions come from

Craft convention: a softer, higher-stearic shaving soap between a hard puck and a cream, at the top of the usual 30 to 50 % stearic range. Potassium hydroxide does 60 % of the saponification, our choice for a soft puck, between Thomssen's cold-made shaving soap (Soap-Making Manual, 1922, about 45 %) and the 74 to 83 % of published shaving creams (Keithler, 1955; Harry's Cosmeticology). The superfat is 4 % rather than 2 % so that the published saponification ranges of these oils cannot leave it lye-heavy. It is cooked as our shaving soap guide teaches, with glycerin stirred in after the cook because free stearic acid makes none.

All recipes